View the above clip – Yellow is clearly fouled inside the 22 and takes a quick self pass whilst Black remains inside the 5m area of the free hit.
Free hit to Yellow?
Free hit to Black?
Play On?
PC to Yellow?
Leave your answer and a brief reason in the comments below. The correct decision will be published soon.
I am glad this one has come up – because I am very foggy in this area
Firstly: I am of the very strong opinion (so as to be fair to the umpire and the “defending” team) that a clear effort should be made to “stop the ball” before a “self pass” can be taken – but I see this happening less and less – so I guess my opinion doesn’t count
Secondly: Yellow was happy to run at an angle away from black and as black did not impede in any way, I guess that is fine, but where do we draw the line? What if Yellow chose the most direct route (straight into black) and 1) ran into black or 2) black reaches the 5m mark but as a result of black not “getting out of the way” yellow was not able to progress fast enough.
A silly comparison: in netball the offending player must go stand next to the person winning the penalty and may not interfer in the initial move. this gives the attacking team the rightful advantage it deserves.
I guess my call (as things stand at the moment) in PLAY ON – but I would love to hear your advice and opinions
This will always come down to the umpires interpretation of what has happened.
In this case I think the umpire has done it perfectly, yellow has gone around black just as black has made a clear effort to get out the way. The only thing that could change is that the ball was not clearly “dead” before the free hit was taken. But as it has no real advantage to the yellow player, or disadvantage to the black player then there is no reason to stop play or to award a penalty corner.
There are just way too many variations that could happen, if the defender makes no attempt to get away from the fowl and interferes with play, then one may upgrade the free hit to a penalty corner. But if the attacker runs a direct line into the defender, weather the defender is trying to get out the way or standing still, then I would think that the free hit should be awarded to the defender.
At the end of the day, make the decision you feel is right and stick to it!
Cheers
TG & Dylan – good analysis! The Black player is clearly making every attempt to get out and makes no attempt to interfere/play the ball and the Yellow player takes a line where he is totally unimpeded. Even if yellow had ran at Black, in view of the fact that Black is trying to move away another free hit would be in order NOT a PC.
As far as stopping the ball is concerned, good points made but we need to bear in mind that the object of the self pass rule is to enhance the flow of the game so a little latitude is good. I would like to think that the Ump may have had a quiet informal word with Yellow and only penalise if repeated, and certainly just running on with the ball cannot be allowed – players need to show that they are making an attempt to stop the ball.
New clip soon!
Thanks Dennis
That helps a little – I guess a quiet word to both teams before the game letting them know how you intend to blow the game RE: Self pass, would also make everything a little more clearer.
I have to agree with Dennis here. You are there to see a game of hockey and not to be over-pedantic and technical. You are there to encourage playing and to let the game flow. Being pedantic can only lead to a stop-start situation, which in turn leads to player frustration, which leads to far worse situations for you to manage. Only interfere when necessary. That is the secret of good umpring – learning when to blow and when to let play go
Play on! There are many situations that could have developed after this one, but don’t go out and look for them – don’t scratch where it is not itchy! Be alert for them and realise they could happen, but manage the situation as it happens and develops – don’t assume.
Fully agree with the play on verdict. In the new rules and umpiring brief they only talk about the attacker who is less than 5m but not affecting play. Perhaps the FIH can add this scenario in future editions!
I fully agree with the “play on” ruling. In the 2011 rules and umpires briefing, there is talk about an umpire using descretion when a team mate is within 5m in the 23m but not affecting play, perhaps the FIH rules guys could add this as a comment. It’s almost like the decisions of golf, where they report on the application of the actual rules in real siutations!
Nothing wrong-play on. The self-pass was given, player yellow made play, black made an effort not to interfer- yellow took chance and made a bad pass and lost it- or advantage played for yellow who made a bad pass and lost an opourtunity-(tough)-play on
PICTURE THIS:
Short Corner is awarded, A player then breaks early, causing him to be sent to the halfway line.
During the next Short Corner a defending player place his foot in the way of a deflection towards the target. The Short corner is not over, and another corner awarded.
Does the player from the half way get to come back ?
My argument… NO.. As the infringement could have been deliberate to allow the player to come back from the half way line, although it has happened, umpires blowing it the other way.
Any Thoughts…
Shane
If the foot was deemed to be deliberate then a Penalty Stroke should have been awarded! I presume that at the new corner, the defending team would then be entitled to a full quota of defenders – Dennis?
Your article offerѕ confirmed useful to mе.
It’s quite educаtional and you rеally аre сlearlу extremеly educated іn thiѕ fiеld.
You haѵe рopped my ρeгsonal eye in oгdеr to different thoughts about this subjеct matter with intriguing and sound content matеriаl.
my web page: Elvis
Your articlе ρrovides vеrified helρful tο me ρeгѕonally.
It’s extrеmely informative anԁ you reаlly
аrе obνiously νery еxρerienced in
this гegion. Yоu gеt opened up mу own sight in orԁer to
numerоus opіniοn оf thіs рarticulaг subject mаttег togethеr ωith inteгеsting anԁ
sounԁ articles.
my hоmepаge – viagra
The post offeгs сonfirmed helpful to myself.
It’ѕ extremеly uѕeful and you’re simply obviously very experienced in this field. You possess popped my personal face in order to various opinion of this subject matter along with intriguing, notable and reliable content.
my page: buy phentermine
Youг articlе рroνiԁeѕ estаblіshed benеficial to me peгsonally.
Ӏt’ѕ rеallу useful and уοu’re clearly very educated of this type. You get opened up my own face in order to different views on this specific matter using intriguing, notable and strong content.
Also visit my homepage … viagra online
It is peгfect tіme to make some ρlanѕ fοr the
longеr term anԁ it’s time to be happy. I’ve leаrn this submit
аnd if I may I wish to counsel you ѕome attention-grаbbіng isѕues
оr tipѕ. Perhaρs yοu сan write next aгticles rеlating to this articlе.
I desіre to rеаd evеn more issuеs approxіmately it!
Нere iѕ my web-sitе: soma
045f93aba43b478a6443dafe5431ab0a
Peculіaг aгticlе, еxаctly what Ӏ was looking fοr.
This is а verу good tip еspecially tο those new to the blogosphеre.
Short but very pгeciѕe info… Appгeciatе уour sharing this one.
Α must read pοst!
I need to to thank you for this great read!! I absolutely enjoyed every little
bit of it. I’ve got you book-marked to check out new things you post…
I blog quіte oftеn and I truly thаnk уou for
your іnformаtіοn. Thіs gгеat article has
reallу ρeаkеԁ mу interest.
I’m going to book mark your website and keep checking for new information about once per week. I subscribed to your Feed as well.
This paragraph gives clear idea in support of the new
viewers of blogging, that actually how to do running a blog.
Attractive section of content. I simply stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to claim that
I acquire in fact enjoyed account your weblog posts.
Anyway I’ll be subscribing for your feeds and even I success you get entry to persistently rapidly.
Ηeу Τherе. I founԁ youг
blog using msn. Thіs iѕ a really neаtly ωritten агticle.
I’ll be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thank you for the post. I’ll definitely comebacκ.
I agree using Nabeel they are really possessing rear for the next launch on these types of functions, whenever they start a more recent type soon they will bring in more money. Cheap Oakley Sunglasses
On the web a new just a passer-by. OK, Abandon the some thing inside your blog exclusively for your current come back take a look at. slendertone Flex
Joel I do think you need to assert the right for you to new music the same as the to healthcare and after that we can easily almost all require the fact that grimy abundant musicians along with track record corporations have got to source the idea for you to all of us. I believe that a open public choice would also usually be necessary. relaxation . Mike Discover how the term “fine” is actually chucked concerning? Pay out for just a loss is apparently considered as a superb as well as a great levied by means of personal entity. Just one factor of numerous incorrect with this particular. The particular honor accessed next to you was radical connected with collection. Shoplifting might generally end up being $125. 00 if this could be considered any “fine. ” The company in which acquired my family produced an incorrect complaint mentioning My spouse and i viewed there television computer programming when i was obviously a paid out client. Many people identified as that a good as well. Despite the fact that presently there the courtroom criticism must have been a dupery and not genuine, not a soul truly cared and that i could not can afford to pay for court for a trial run. In fact falsified movie proof seemed to be developed with no one particular blinked a watch. Instances where scams is actually permitted or perhaps reimbursement is actually way out of brand will certainly meet up with all of our the legal program for the reason that every time it take place, that system looses reliability that you can study in the articles and reviews over zygor. If fake court issues usually are permitted and also awards are so from collection it can be certain our system is not reasonable and equitable. Oakley Sunglasses Outlet
As mentioned, thousands of people have already seen life changing results after using Kyle Leon’s Muscle Maximizer for just a few weeks, and there is nothing that says that you can’t experience the same changes as well.
Except this is exactly what does happen, frequently in badly considered
build muscle strategies. Who is this Somanabolic Muscle Maximizer Training Software
Designed For.
Also visit my weblog :: Somanabolic Muscle Maximizer Review
I read this post completely regarding the comparison of
hottest and earlier technologies, it’s amazing article.
I blog frequently and I really thank you for your content.
This article has really peaked my interest. I’m going to book mark your website and keep checking for new details about once per week. I opted in for your RSS feed too.
the content of the site is informative, bookmarked it to check the updates from this site
very interesting articles, well happy to have this blog
Various Tips That you Give Valuable And Intriguing Presentation
I like what you guys are up too. This type of clever work
and reporting! Keep up the great works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to blogroll.